Home
Topics
Images
Martial Fighters
VMAC 2007
Bruce's Movies
Jackie's Movies
MA Movie Top 100
Jeet Kune Do
Books & DVD's
More Links
Bruce-VS-Jackie.com
is an open community for martial arts movie fans

Updated: Thu 16.Oct.08 01:27
Online for 2308 days
2003 members

Registered members can leave comments, start discussions and add images.

Martial Arts Top 20

1. Bruce Lee
2. Jackie Chan
3. Jet Li
4. Steven Seagal
5. Jean Claude van Damme
6. Tony Jaa
7. Donnie Yen
8. Cynthia Rothrock
9. Michelle Yeoh
10. Sammo Hung
11. Brandon Lee
12. Bolo Yeung
13. Chow Yun Fat
14. Wesley Snipes
15. Shintaro Katsu
16. Pei Pei Cheng
17. Zhang Ziyi
18. Billy Chow
19. Stephan Chow
20. Chuck Norris

   | Archive
Complete list

Virtual Martial Arts Championship 2009

Style vs. Style

I wanted to make a big, hypothetical 16 man tournament between martial arts styles. There is no human factor in it, and wins are decided on the training and exercises of the style.

The rules are pretty simple. They fight in a big, pit like structure that you can't exit, and they don't get any weapons. They do get to wear their uniforms from their particular style, but no shoes. You fight until a knockout, surrender, or possibly death. No outside interference is allowed in the ring, but you can have trainers shout instructions to you.

Here's the bracket:

Taekwondo vs Ninjitsu

Kempo Karate vs. Kickboxing

American Kickboxing vs. Muay Thai Kickboxing

Judo vs. Pencak Silat

San Soo Kung-Fu vs. Sambo

Wing-Chun or Military Combat vs. Streetfighting ( In this case, it's Boxing plus karate)

Five Animal Kung-Fu or Aikido vs. Wing-Chun

Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu vs. Full-Contact Karate

It's a one night tournament, and the winner of each first fight battles the winner of the next fight( For example, the winner of Taekwondo vs Ninjitsu fights the winner of Kempo Karate vs. Kickboxing.)

I want opinions. Finish the bracket on who you think would win until the finals ( 16 man 1 prelim, 1 quarte final,1 semifinal, and one final.)

Share/Save/Bookmark  Subscribe
Article by: kingofruas, Sunday, 4. March 2007, 22:59h
Add comment  (25 comments)


hm... interesting

Taekowndo vs Ninjitsu = Ninjitsu

Kempo Karate vs Kickboxing = Kempo

American Kickboxing vs Muay Thai = Muay thai

Judo vs Pencak Silat = Judo

San Soo Kung Fu vs Sambo = San soo Kung Fu

Wing Chun vs Streetfighting = Wing CHun

Five animal kung fu vs Wing Chun = Five animal (for two reason. 1. i am a five animal practitioner, 2. i just beat equivilent of my rank in wing chun in a full contact fight...)

Brazilian Ju-jitsu vs full contact karate = BJJ

link 

Style VS Style

Teakwondo VS Ninjutsu
With weapons: Ninjutsu
Without: Teakwondo has a chance

Kempo VS Kickboxing
In real: Kempo
In the Ring: Kickboxing (due to the rules)

Judo VS Silat: Silat

San Soo VS Sambo: San Soo

Wing Chun VS Streetfighting: Wing Chun is streetfighting.

5 Animal Kung Fu VS Wing Chun: Wing Chun (I am a Wing Chun practioner and beat all other Kung Fu styles so far, same or higher ranks)

BJJ VS Full Contact Karate:
In real the Karate person has a chance if he is quick, in the ring he has no chance.

link 

Tournament

Would be fun to start a tournament indeed, with 32 styles. I suppose it would be more fun to use an island in a ring of fire instead of a pit. No weapons, no protection material etc... We can start the first round next week, just add your styles and we will start the fights! Will be fun. Here is a suggestion for 32 styles (in random order):

1. Boxing
2. Shaolin Long Fist
3. Shotokan Karate
4. Kyokushin Karate
5. Wado Karate
6. Ashihara Karate
7. Muay Thai
8. Thai Boran
9. Hapkido
10. Taekwondo
11. Wing Chun
12. Hung Gar Kung Fu
13. Capoeira
14. Savate
15. Aikido
16. Jiu Jitsu
17. Brazillian Jiu Jitsu
18. American Kempo
19. Glima
20. Five Animals Kung Fu
21. Drunken Style Kung Fu
22. Pak Mee Pai
23. Pencak Silat
24. Ching Yi Kung Fu
25. Krav Maga
26. Systema
27. Sambo
28. Wrestling
29. Judo
30. Ninjutsu
31. Kickboxing
32. Jeet Kune Do

link 

Traditional WING CHUN!!!

link 

Tournament

Let me know if you all can agree with the same rules as in the VMAC. Fights for one week so everybody has the possibility to vote.

Option 1 (one to one fights)

First week: 8 fights (first 16 fighters)
Second week: 8 fights (second 16 fighters)
Third week: 8 fights (quarter finals)
Fourth week: 4 fights (half finals)
Fiftht week: 2 fights (quarter finals)
Sixth week: Final fight

Option 2 (4 at the same time in one fight)

First week: 8 fights with 4 fighters (quarter finals)
Second week: 4 fights of 2 fighters (half final)
Third week: 1 fight with 4 fighters (final)

Option 3:

First week: 8 fights with 4 fighters (quarter finals)
Second week: 2 fights of 4 fighters (half final)
Third week: 1 fight with 2 fighters (final)

Option 4:

First week: 1 fight with 8 fighters
Second week: 1 fight with 8 fighters
Third week: 1 fight with 8 fighters
Fourth week: 1 fight with 8 fighters
Fifth week: Final with 4 fighters

Please let me know what option you like.

I will make 32 pieces of paper this week and let my girlfriend pick them so we can start the tournament on monday!

link 

Actually, I was implying no rules in the first place............

And this has already been done. It was the bracket for UFC 2.


Prelimanary

Taekwondo vs. Ninjitsu: Ninjitsu by choke.

Kempo vs. Kickboxing: Kickboxing by choke.

American Kickboxing vs. Muay Thai: Muay Thai by ground strikes.

Judo vs. Silat: Judo by choke.

San Soo vs. Sambo: Sambo by submission.

Wing Chun vs. Streetfighting ( Guy was actually listed as a karate man, but resorted to brawling and boxing tactics): Streetfighting by Headbutts.

5-Animals vs. Wing Chun: 5-animals by triangle choke.

BJJ vs. Karate: BJJ by armbar.



Quarter Finals

Kickboxing vs. Ninjitsu: Kickboxing by ground strikes.

Muay Thai vs. Judo: Judo by knockout (ground strikes).

Streetfighting vs. Karate ( Sambo man dropped out of tournament): Streetfighting by choke.

BJJ vs. Kung-Fu: BJJ by armbar.


Semi-Finals

Kickboxing vs. Streetfighting: Kickboxing by choke.

BJJ vs. Judo: BJJ by gi choke.

Championship Round:

BJJ vs. Kickboxing: After a quick scuffle on the feet, they go to the ground where the kickboxer taps out from punches.

It was the largest UFC tournament. I just wanted to see who you guys would think would win. But I think the vote thing would be fun, anyway. Maybe you can invent how the fighter won.

link 

You should put Sumo wrestling in the bracket to show to big contrast between martial arts styles.

link 

it all depends on the fighters in reality, cause lotsa people might say outta karate n BJJ, BJJ wud win but in reality it depends,, has the karate guy any knowledge of ground fighting, does he have the strength to resist the BJJ fighter, can he knock the guy out before he is taken down? loadsa factors. like i once saw a wing Chun guy bare knuckle against a BJJ guy n the BJJ guy won but the Wing Chun guy just froze on the ground, when in reality Wing Chun actualy does have ground fighting application. also he wasnt thinkin clearly enough to hit the guy first.

link 

Well, real fighters did compete in the actual bracket. Royce gracie was the BJJ guy.

link 

yeah but wot im sayin is it dnt matter cos da fighter dat fought him wouldnt be as gd as sy the grand master or woteva.
newho can we add drunken boxing in somewhere?

link 

I think the alternative karate guy ( Fred Ettish) who fought the streetfighter ( Johnny Rhodes) was a grand master. He lost.

There was also Ron Van Clief, 10th degree blackbelt in Chinese Goju, who lost in UFC 4.

link 

omigodomigodomigodomigod!

I tuched meself at da thout od dis. although it's true dat no style is better than another, any smart marshal artist bwill aknowladge tht some styles are better than other styles. u canhotargue wit my hippokritikal logick!

dickhead kingofous dinks dat dis akually happened, butt i now beater! dis neber happened! hear r me brackets, and they are trrue 100 perkent ub de time!

Tai kwan doo vs. ninjotsu: TKKD is a malitary stayle, bitch is cool, butt ninjitsu has mo' lethal moves! ...... Ninjitsu by death!

kempo krotty vs. shitboxing: HAHAHA! U canhot compare! kickboxingers all fit using rules, wile ruthless and resourcefull karate ppl dont! even do they practice similar techniques, and dat kikboxers us de teknique gainst live peple, kempo still wins!

American Kickboxing vs Muay Thai; Llolololl slapfigt!

Jewdo vs. Pecake Silat: haha. ado judo is asian, its still a spart! spiorts don wrk in fits! silat had a vidao game made about it, so iy mus b good! Silat for da win!

San Soo Kung Fu vs Sambo: sane ding as above. Sambo is a spotr! LOL! San soo is rutless and is lik sistema!!! KUNG-FU POWA!!!!!

Wing Chun vs Streetfighting : KUNG-FU POWA, KUN-FU POWA! LOL, PENISFUCKER!

Five animal kung fu/aikdo vs Wing Chun : chun is better sdan 5-animals, but aikido is tuff!!!! beest fit o de night! i dink dat either aikido or wing chun will win!

Brazilian Ju-jitsu vs full contact karate : hahaha. BJ is a sport! it never beet any real mrtial arts! karate can stoop takedown wit forehead punch!!!!! you cannot argue wit my logic!!!!!!!!!!!!!

If anyone diasageres wit meee i will kill you!!!!!!

link 

You are an idiot... Next time u leave a post, spell the words correctly so people can understand it... Muay Thai a slap-fight? Kickboxing a slap-fight? Im not even going to justify that... Although Muay Thai is a lot harder... Oh, and BJJ would totally destroy FC Karate. Aikido isnt tough either...

link 

FF

i punched me compoter agan wen u zed dat!!!!! me dont undarstaand y ppl disabree wit mee nowing full well dat ill kill dem!!!!!!!!!!!

how cum u didnt agree wit mee and gibe me a virtualist blow job like everyone elsde does???? SUK MI COK! Ohhhh i get it! how old is u? i beet you don't eben practice marshal arts eitha.

if u ware smrt like me, u wood know dat kickboxin sucks an dat all tradationa marshtial arts are great!!!! karate wood stoop bj takdowns wit a forehead punche, an aikdo is badas!!!! ol' ppl dew it!
You cannnot arguee wit mi logick!

IF YOU DISABGRE WIT MI I WIL KILL YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
and lrn to read you fag!

link 

Everyone civilized on this site knows your an idiot...

link 

lsten fag! I haive it 'bout up to her wit u....... grow upp, bend over, and SUX MY COCK!!@@ and kiss my ass whil u down there.///// .

haha, i beet ur rly inmitdated bi me!!!! ur scarreed op me and dats Y u whine!!! u beater note mesh wite me, cuz i know kung-fu and an a mastor of maany stiles. u obviously donnt know any marshal arts!!!!! hhhaaaahhaha, whiump!!!

link 

So when's this goingto start?

link 

Hahaha, your not being scary, really you just making a fool of yourself... Just forget it. Oh, and train in Traditional Wing Chun.

Really, no-one cares anymore...

link 

omg

i think he spelt a few words right...
how cute, our little boy is growing up

link 

hey five animals

hey wassup, been a while since i've been on here. i think the last time i was on here i was talking about a fight i was going to be having. well, i've actually had 5 fights since then. i thought i'd add that they were all won by knockout. well except for one really. that was won by disqualification (the guy turned is back and ran, lol). anyways i've just been too busy with training and work to come by the site lately. oh yea, i was wondering what was up with all the porn stuff. this is a martial arts website right?

link 

hey

congrats on your fights. a guy ran away in a ring fight?! pussy... o well
the pron stuff i'm about to get rid off. Since this is a free to anyone site, people place their unwanted ads on where. This one guys pops up around once a week/two weeks... just ignore it, don't click on it

link 

uhm...

just wondering, but does anyone remembers me from the good ol' days... 5animals? i know you do, buddy... buttbuddy... ANYwhy, following those recent, uhm, enlightnening coments by dazodiac, do i seem less of a (how should i put this) "PENISFUCKER" (not my words, mind you...) don't worry... i probably won't stay on this site, or visit it very often, but it would do great things for my battered & bruised psyche if i knew that i had gained at least somewhat of a non-criminal status here at your esteemed webpage... but, if that cannot be, if i have already damned myself to an eternity of burning in effigy... well, that's okay as well... i just thought i'd try again to make nice.

Oh, and for the record... back in my glory days, i was by far a better antagonizer than this new little shit, wasn't i? you must admit that i had a certain amount of genious... evil genious, yes... but still, back me up here, willya?

well guys, it's been grand, but i must once again hit the ol' dusty trail... i'll come back... one day. maybe it will be soon... maybe not. but one thing is certain: i am. so, in the meantime, don't die. and try your hardest not to get lost...

cheers

link 

mi estilo...

you guys have put up some good arguments for your favorite styles, but all of the ones you named pale in comparison with the style i know to be the ultimate.... all confusing and superfluously complicated sentence structures aside, the most dominant style is...
DOGGY STYLE
i mean, really.... just think about it

link 

Muay Thai is the great Martial art form around. Tony Jaa you will make it to the very top like Bruce Lee did. I know you will I love you.

link 

#8 is wrong there is no Thai Boran its Muay Boran or Muay Thai or Krabi Krabong. These are the nastiest martial art forms in the whole world in my opinion.
Tony Jaa you rock my world I love you baby always and forever. C U in my dreams Cutie

link 


Your Status
You're not logged in ... login
Movie of the Week
Add comment  (no comments) | Archive
Latest comments
belt system
that is true but you should still be respected for having achieved status in the first place shouldnt you? British and American war veterans in World War 2 fought to protect the free world but some may be alchoholics who do nothing constructive all day. However they should still be proud that they sacrificed themselves for a liberal society shouldnt they?
by Kungfuhonour on 2008.10.16, 01:27
Martial arts movies
Martial Arts movies, you either love them or you hate them. There is no middle ground. They invoke passion on either side. If you love them you'll probably watch any old rubbish so long as there is some chance of someone getting a kick to the head. What's more you will probably even get a kick (pun totally intended) out of the cheesy badly dubbed dialogue. Classic lines to be found in almost any Chinese movie are, "My uncle sent...
by archibald on 2008.10.15, 20:38
Tae kwon do
|'ve been doing tae kwon do for five years (but i'm only a blue belt, cant afford the gradings, collage student) now and i do have the ablity to take on some black belts but from what i've found is that it's the club that you join in my club i have a mixture of tae kwon do, mui thai, karete, and kickboxing and most of my masters are ex-pros so i get lots of experience. Also my brother does...
by Herbie_19 on 2008.10.10, 10:52
taekwondo championship
i want to play the taekwondo championship if there is any tournament then pl. do contact me as soon as possible
by ashwani on 2008.10.10, 09:33
Learning
www.yantaikungfu.com I was student in the school.unfortunately I left in advance last winter .At that moment,there are only several students. you know ,the terrible cold day outside ,the ice-cold room inside,he didn’t even provide any heat system.and deducted more than forty percent of my deserved refund without any reasons when I left earlier, a fake. more,I have heared from the translator that the true name of school is not “traditional kungfu school.he just put it into the internet.which put a cheat...
by Benweek4 on 2008.09.09, 01:32
pi**ed off sigung
people forget that sigung gathered a concept of ideas that suited him at the time, yes it was given a name but it was never a set system of martial art, ive studied a form of jkd for many years now but feel that too much is put on the idea of it being bruce lees product and something that can be bought, what jkd is for me isnt what it is for anyother in the world, its how you...
by frankfredrickson on 2008.09.03, 10:32
Steven Seagal's Doing Something....
Steven Seagal is doing something to better this planet that we all live on! What are you complainers doing--- oh yea that's right complaining instead of getting off your couches and helping to better the world around you! Can any of you say that you've stuck with a teaching or interest for more then a couple days or weeks? Well Steven Seagal Most Certainly Can!!! All Props to You Steven Keep Going We as A Human Race Need More People...
by BodiEire on 2008.08.30, 20:53
Hey, I really like this forum.
It's cool to see what other people think and believe about some of the most famous martial artists. I was reading gunz's and lohan?'s comments, and then looked at the long list, and stopped reading right around where lohan said that he respected gunz. idk, if this forum is outdated, and that my comment will mean nothing... but here are my two cents anyway... Bruce Lee is great. Jet Li is great. Jackie Chan... is just crazy. Ha :) I think that...
by Bourne Philosophy on 2008.08.27, 03:08
Why Jackie chan would not last 1 round with bruce lee.
Bruce Lees style that he created himself jeet kwan do. (the art on no style). Ranked supreme during his time it broke down the all of the of the flaws of gung fu, kung fu, shaolin, boxing mu thai, judo etc. Jeet kwan do was all of the style combined into one style. If Jackie chan came at bruce with just his simple shaolin munk fighting style it would only be seconds before Bruce Lee would pick him apart. I...
by hammy sammy on 2008.08.10, 18:37
Bruce lee is the greatest "why?"
Bruce lee is the greatest because he was the best at every popular fighting style at his time. If he lived in our era he would have studied brazilian jui jitzu and all of the other styles that have emerged in the ufc, k-1 etc. The best fighter is the who can adapt to all styles and that was what bruce lee was all about he trained and worked harder than any fighter ever. If there was a modern day...
by hammy sammy on 2008.08.10, 18:21
Special Offers
VMAC 2009

XML version of this page

Please use this logo to link to this pages:

logo for links

version 7.02 - copyright Bruce VS Jackie 2006